Two Way Limits

It does not happen often, but when it does, it's simply beautiful: a question with two completely different yet right answers. I saw such question on Yahoo Answers today. Although I didn't answer it, the two different answers were so interesting and different in their approach, I had to bring it here.

The question is quite simple for people who know limits, but the two different answers are just amazing.

Find the limit:
lim_{x -> 4} (3 - (5 + x)^1/2) / (1 - (5 - x)^1/2)

As you can clearly see, plugging x = 4 gives a zero in the denominator, which is why the question asks for a limit. You can plug in numbers and get a rough estimation, but we want a definite answer.

The first method is using L'Hopital's rule. This rule says that in order to find lim_{x -> a} f(x)/g(x), you can also find lim_{x -> a} f'(x)/g'(x). All we need now is to differentiate the numerator and denominator and see what we get:
lim_{x -> 4} (-1/2 * (5 + x)^-1/2) / (1/2 * (5 - x)^-1/2)

The halves cancel, and by using the law that says aⁿ / bⁿ = (a/b)ⁿ, we can show that:
lim_{x -> 4} -((5 + x) / (5 - x))^-1/2

Now plug in 4 and you will get -((5 + 4)/(5-4))^-1/2
Which is -9^-1/2 = -1/3

This is one very good solution, and most people who know calculus would choose that. However, there is another solution to this problem. To do that, multiply the numerator and denominator by the conjugate of the denominator:
lim_{x -> 4} (3 - (5 + x)^1/2) / (1 - (5 - x)^1/2) * (1 + (5 - x)^1/2) / (1 + (5 - x)^1/2)

Using the law that says (a + b)(a - b) = a² - b² and the distributive property, we can conclude that:
lim_{x -> 4} (3 - (5 + x)^1/2) * (1 + (5 - x)^1/2) / (1 - (5 - x))
lim_{x -> 4} (3 - (5 + x)^1/2) * (1 + (5 - x)^1/2) / (x - 4)

Now multiply both parts of the fraction by the conjugate of the original numerator:
lim_{x -> 4} (3 - (5 + x)^1/2) * (1 + (5 - x)^1/2) / (x - 4) * (3 + (5 + x)^1/2) / (3 + (5 + x)^1/2)
lim_{x -> 4} (9 - (5 + x)) * (1 + (5 - x)^1/2) / ((x - 4) * (3 + (5 + x)^1/2))
lim_{x -> 4} (4 - x) * (1 + (5 - x)^1/2) / ((x - 4) * (3 + (5 + x)^1/2) )

That is really nice. (4 - x) / (x - 4) = -1, so we can cancel out two terms and turn them into a nice little minus sign:
lim_{x -> 4} -(1 + (5 - x)^1/2) / (3 + (5 + x)^1/2)

Now we can safely plug 4 for x and we get:
-(1 + (5 - 4)^1/2) / (3 + (5 + 4)^1/2)
-(1 + 1^1/2) / (3 + 9^1/2)
-(1 + 1) / (3 + 3)
-1/3

Again, we get -1/3 as an answer.

Math can be very easy if you think outside the box. Try doing it as often as you can.
Nadav

nadavs